In folklore and mythology, healers and witches often occupy contrasting, yet overlapping roles. Both of these archetypes have been present throughout history in various cultures around the world. While their methods and intentions may differ, they both possess a deep understanding of the supernatural and the ability to exert influence over the physical and spiritual realms. Healers, commonly known as shamans, medicine men or women, are individuals who use their knowledge of herbs, rituals, and spiritual practices to restore health and balance to individuals and communities. They draw upon their connection with nature and the spirit world to diagnose ailments and provide treatment. Healers are often revered for their ability to heal physical ailments, but they also possess knowledge of the psychological and emotional aspects of well-being.
An introspective historical fantasy . . Werlin’s gentle reflection on trauma and healing, the ethics of power, and seemingly dual natures explores Sylvie’s place in the world and her relationship to those she cares for.
—Publishers Weekly
Sylvie and her mother and grandmother are beloved, trusted healers in their medieval French village, though some whisper that fifteen-year-old Sylvie and her grand-mere deal in more than herbs and medicines. When her grandmother dies, and Sylvie s mother no longer remembers her because of Sylvie s mistake, the teen has to leave her small, Catholic village to find anyone who can teach her how to control her great power.
Healers are often revered for their ability to heal physical ailments, but they also possess knowledge of the psychological and emotional aspects of well-being. On the other hand, witches are believed to possess supernatural powers that allow them to manipulate the natural world for their own gain or to harm others. Often portrayed as practitioners of dark magic, witches are associated with curses, potions, and spells.
Review of Healer and Witch
Werlin’s new novel is cause for celebration—for its sleek, sharp prose; intelligent ideas; and precise characterization, to name but a few of its attr.
Healer and Witch
by Nancy Werlin
Middle School Candlewick 304 pp. g
3/22 978-1-5362-1956-2 $19.99
e-book ed. 978-1-5362-2457-3 $19.99
Werlin’s new novel is cause for celebration—for its sleek, sharp prose; intelligent ideas; and precise characterization, to name but a few of its attributes. Set in 1531 France, this is the tale of Sylvie, an untaught telepathic healer, who, after the death of her grand-mère, mistakenly removes much of her mother’s memory while trying to ease her grief. In the company of clever, rambunctious young neighbor Martin, Sylvie leaves her tiny hamlet in quest of a mentor to teach her how to use her powers safely; the two travel to Lyon with the caravan of an enterprising trader to find the renowned magic-user Madame du Bois. But both Madame du Bois and the trader turn out to be something of a surprise—and will Lyon’s new inquisitor prove to be a help to Sylvie, or a danger? Every sentence here pushes character and plot forward, so there’s plenty of momentum and suspense; but what is more unusual is the way Werlin prods characters (and readers) to think through ideas of faith and reason in making their own choices. The story has its articulate and challenging “lessons” (for instance, even after you discover who it is you’re meant to be, “you must work hard every day to become that person”). Just as much, it invites questions and rigorous reasoning, refusing to bow to romantic sentiment (“But men owned their wives,” Sylvie thinks, considering the legal realities of marriage). A refreshingly honest and elegantly written work of historical fantasy.
From the May/June 2022 issue of The Horn Book Magazine.
Gr 5-8–In 16th-century France, 15-year-old Sylvie, her mother, and Grand-mere are healers; Grand-mere and Sylvie’s abilities are rooted in magic, however. When her grandmother dies, and Sylvie’s mother no longer remembers her because of Sylvie’s mistake, the teen has to leave her small, Catholic village to find anyone who can teach her how to control her great power. She is accompanied by Martin, a younger childhood friend, who was asked by Grand-mere to follow Sylvie if the girl ever left the village. She meets the wise woman Ceciline, one of Grand-mere’s former friends. Ceciline may be like Sylvie’s Grand-mere, but her feelings about people without magic are completely different. The young woman uses her power, which is much greater than anyone else’s, to find her own path forward. Werlin’s middle grade debut features adventure, magic, and a strong female protagonist. This suspenseful historical fantasy explores how society perceives and attempts to control women, especially those who are seen as strong, wise, or powerful.
However, not all witches are perceived as evil; some are portrayed as wise and benevolent beings who use their powers for the greater good, similar to healers. The distinction between healers and witches can sometimes be blurred, as both share a connection to the spirit realm and possess knowledge of herbalism and ritual practices. In some cultures, healers may also be seen as witches or vice versa, depending on the societal perception. The same individual may be viewed as a healer or a witch depending on the context and the intention behind their actions. Overall, the roles of healers and witches exemplify the human fascination with the supernatural and the desire to harness these powers for personal or communal well-being. While healers focus on physical, emotional, and spiritual healing, witches tap into the mysteries of the natural and supernatural world for various purposes. Despite their distinctions and occasional overlap, both healers and witches have played significant roles in shaping folklore and mythology, leaving enduring impressions on human culture and imagination..
Reviews for "The Witch's Brew: Potions and Elixirs for Healing and Magic"
1. John - 2/5 - I found "Healer and Witch" to be a disappointing read. The plot was predictable and lacked depth, making it difficult for me to become invested in the story. The characters were also flat and lacked complexity, which made it hard to empathize with their struggles. Additionally, the writing style felt juvenile and often had awkward or cliché dialogue. Overall, "Healer and Witch" fell short of my expectations and I wouldn't recommend it.
2. Sarah - 1/5 - I couldn't finish "Healer and Witch" as it failed to capture my interest from the beginning. The pacing was incredibly slow, with little action or suspense to move the story forward. The world-building was also lacking, leaving me confused and disconnected from the setting. Moreover, the protagonist seemed one-dimensional and lacked any depth or growth. The writing style was monotonous and lacked creativity. Unfortunately, "Healer and Witch" was a complete miss for me.
3. Emily - 2/5 - While the concept of "Healer and Witch" had potential, it ultimately fell flat for me. The plot felt disjointed and lacked a cohesive narrative, making it difficult to follow and become invested in the story. The characters were underdeveloped and lacked depth, which made it hard to connect with their experiences. Additionally, the writing style was mediocre and often filled with unnecessary descriptions that added little to the overall story. Overall, "Healer and Witch" was a disappointment and not a book I would recommend.